Whitening is one of the most popular cosmetic dental treatments, and you can buy it everywhere from the dentist’s office to the pharmacy aisle. Here is how the main options compare, what the ADA Seal tells you, and what whitening can and cannot change.
Start with why your teeth are discolored
Whitening works better on some stains than others, so the cause matters. The American Dental Association (ADA) groups stains into two broad types.
Surface (extrinsic) stains
These sit on the outside of the tooth. Coffee, tea, red wine, cola and tobacco are common causes. Whitening toothpaste or a professional cleaning often helps with these.
Deeper (intrinsic) stains
These are inside the tooth. Causes include aging (enamel thins and the yellower layer underneath shows through), injury to a tooth, too much fluoride while teeth were forming, and certain medications, such as tetracycline or doxycycline taken while teeth were developing. Some of these respond to bleaching and some do not.
According to the ADA’s consumer site, MouthHealthy, yellow teeth usually bleach well, brown teeth may respond less, and gray teeth may not bleach at all. Discoloration caused by medications or a tooth injury may not improve with whitening.
Your whitening options
Most whitening products use a peroxide, either hydrogen peroxide or carbamide peroxide, which breaks down into hydrogen peroxide. The main differences between options are the strength of the product, how long it is applied, and how closely a dentist is involved.
Whitening toothpaste
Whitening toothpastes remove surface stains with polishing or chemical agents. MouthHealthy notes that they do not change the natural color of your teeth. They can be a reasonable everyday choice if surface stains are your main concern.
Over-the-counter strips, gels and kits
Pharmacy products such as strips, paint-on gels and tray kits use lower concentrations of bleach than dental offices do. They often take longer to show results. The ADA describes one study in which an over-the-counter product took 16 days to reach the result that an at-home tray system reached in seven days and an in-office treatment reached in one.
Take-home trays from your dentist
Your dentist makes custom trays from impressions of your teeth and gives you a whitening gel to use at home. Because the trays fit closely, the gel stays on your teeth and away from your gums. MouthHealthy describes this as a slower option with professional guidance, typically taking days to weeks.
In-office whitening
A dentist applies a stronger peroxide gel while protecting your gums, sometimes with a light to speed things up. It is usually done in a single visit.
What the ADA Seal means
The ADA Seal of Acceptance shows that a manufacturer has provided evidence that its product meets ADA requirements for safety and effectiveness when used as directed. Some whitening toothpastes and over-the-counter whitening strips carry the Seal.
Two things to know:
- Check the Seal’s wording. A toothpaste may carry the Seal for cavity prevention rather than for whitening. The box should say what the Seal covers.
- Professional products are not eligible. Whitening products dispensed or applied by dentists are not part of the Seal program, so the lack of a Seal on those does not mean anything is wrong with them.
You can search Seal-accepted products on the ADA website.
Is whitening safe?
For most adults, whitening is considered safe when you follow the directions and your dentist has checked your mouth first. The side effects are usually mild and temporary.
Tooth sensitivity
Sensitivity is the most common side effect. Peroxide passes through the enamel and can irritate the nerve of the tooth. The ADA reports that it can affect up to two-thirds of people early in treatment, often starting within the first few days and settling soon after. Higher-strength products and longer treatments are more likely to cause it.
If your teeth become sensitive, MouthHealthy suggests stopping for a while and trying again later. Your dentist can suggest ways to make treatment more comfortable.
Gum irritation
Gum irritation usually comes from gel touching the gums, often because trays do not fit well. A burning feeling can be a sign that the gel is leaking. Rinse and stop, and call your dentist if it continues.
Do not overdo it
Using whiteners more often or longer than directed can damage enamel or gums. More is not better.
Who should talk to a dentist first
Everyone, ideally. Whitening will not fix cavities, gum disease or worn enamel, and a whitening product on an untreated cavity or exposed root can hurt. A quick exam also tells you whether your type of discoloration is likely to respond. The American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry discourages full-mouth cosmetic bleaching for children who still have baby teeth or a mix of baby and adult teeth. If you are pregnant or nursing, ask your dentist before starting any whitening.
What whitening cannot change
Bleaching only works on natural teeth. It will not change the color of:
- Crowns or caps
- Veneers
- Tooth-colored fillings and bonding
- Dental implants
This matters if you have dental work in your front teeth. If you whiten your natural teeth, older crowns or fillings may end up looking darker by comparison, and replacing them to match is a separate cost. Your dentist can help you plan the order of treatment, for example whitening first and then matching any new work to your new shade.
Making your results last
Whitening is not permanent. Coffee, tea, red wine and tobacco will stain teeth again over time. Brushing twice a day with a fluoride toothpaste, regular cleanings and cutting back on staining foods and drinks help. Ask your dentist when and how to touch up.
Questions to ask before you whiten
- Will my type of discoloration respond to whitening?
- Do I have any cavities, gum problems or exposed roots to treat first?
- Will any of my crowns, veneers or fillings show a color mismatch?
- Which option fits my budget and how sensitive my teeth are?
- What is the total cost, including any touch-up gel?
Find a dentist for a whitening consultation
A general dentist can examine your teeth, explain your options and supply custom trays or in-office treatment. Browse general dentists in South Florida, or search by your city or county on our dentist search page. SoFlo Dentists is a directory and does not give dental advice.